Tier 3midrange

Survival Recurring

Survival Toolbox

Featured list~$2616PM Local #13 @ Magic Lair (Torino, Italy)

Overview

"Recurring Survival (Rec-Sur) is a BRG midrange toolbox deck named for its two engines, Recurring Nightmare and Survival of the Fittest, which let it tutor up and loop a deep creature suite. Birds of Paradise and the Wall of Roots/Wall of Blossoms pair ramp and stabilize while Survival fetches answers like Bone Shredder, Uktabi Orangutan, and Withered Wretch, and Squee, Goblin Nabob fuels both Survival discards and Recurring Nightmare loops."

Game Plan

Grind out incremental advantage by chaining Survival of the Fittest and Recurring Nightmare to recur value creatures, then close with Deranged Hermit tokens and beaters like Ravenous Baloth.

Key Cards

Core engine & flex

Survival of the Fittest

$385.40

TCG MP CK

Signature

Birds of Paradise

$18.82

TCG MP CK

Wall of Blossoms

$4.75

TCG MP CK

Deranged Hermit

$83.96

TCG MP CK

Squee, Goblin Nabob

$30.74

TCG MP CK

Wall of Roots

$0.63

TCG MP CK

Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Details

Sample Decklists

Sort By

PM Local #13 @ Magic Lair (Torino, Italy)

1st PlaceMay 27, 2026

Enrico Vair

View full deck page

Enrico Vair

TCG

Mainboard (61)61-card deck

$2430

Creature (27)

$460

$75.28G

$0.372B

$1683GG

$7.744G

$17.592BB

$24.995UU

$42.634

$2.291B

$0.383G

$45.945UU

$1.982B

$16.542GG

$0.841GG

$30.742R

$19.001G

$2.521G

$3.40BB

Sorcery (8)

$114

4Cabal Therapy

$98.92B

4Duress

$14.80B

Enchantment (6)

$1712

2Recurring Nightmare

$1712B

4Survival of the Fittest

$15421G

Land (20)

$144

10Forest

$9.10

4Llanowar Wastes

$132

6Swamp

$2.52

Sideboard (15)

$186

$30.962B

$1262GG

$6.481G

$7.245GW

$1.003BB

$1.852G

$9.075GGG

$3.40BB

Est. Total$2616

Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Details

Premodern LeagueMay112026 (2026-05-11)

1st PlaceMay 11, 2026

bforbernard

View full deck page

bforbernard

TCG

Mainboard (60)

$3857

Creature (25)

$394

$30.742R

$0.383G

$0.31BB

$2.291B

$42.634

$17.592BB

$7.744G

$1683GG

$1.982B

$9.661G

$0.372B

$75.28G

$14.251G

$2.521G

$3.40BB

$16.542GG

Instant (2)

$4.32

2Naturalize

$4.321G

Sorcery (7)

$98.70

1Living Death

$13.413BB

3Duress

$11.10B

3Cabal Therapy

$74.19B

Enchantment (6)

$1712

4Survival of the Fittest

$15421G

2Recurring Nightmare

$1712B

Land (20)

$1648

4Llanowar Wastes

$132

10Forest

$9.10

5Swamp

$2.10

1Gaea's Cradle

$1505

Sideboard (15)

$119

$1.003BB

$0.292GG

$4.321G

$0.252BB

$23.222B

$11.941B

$9.661G

$66.582

$1.852G

Est. Total$3976

Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Details

Mercadian Frogs @ Troll2jeux (Paris, France)

1st PlaceMar 18, 2026

Julien Roqueplan

View full deck page

Julien Roqueplan

TCG

Mainboard (60)

$2370

Creature (26)

$400

$75.28G

$0.372B

$1683GG

$7.744G

$17.592BB

$42.634

$2.291B

$0.383G

$1.982B

$16.542GG

$30.742R

$9.661G

$1.852G

$19.001G

$2.521G

$3.40BB

Sorcery (8)

$114

4Cabal Therapy

$98.92B

4Duress

$14.80B

Enchantment (6)

$1712

2Recurring Nightmare

$1712B

4Survival of the Fittest

$15421G

Land (20)

$144

10Forest

$9.10

4Llanowar Wastes

$132

6Swamp

$2.52

Sideboard (15)

$63.67

$0.372B

$30.962B

$0.252BB

$2.291B

$8.641G

$1.003BB

$0.841GG

$19.321G

Est. Total$2433

Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Details

Archetype Anatomy

Based on 130 decks with known dates2021-05-08 to 2026-06-12

Mana Base

Average20.6lands

Median20lands

Range16–24lands

Spells39.4avg non-land

Based on 129 decks (All-time)

core Cards(>80%)

Survival of the Fittest

100%

4.0x

Birds of Paradise

99%

3.9x

Wall of Blossoms

99%

3.3x

Deranged Hermit

99%

1.7x

Squee, Goblin Nabob

99%

1.0x

Wall of Roots

98%

3.8x

Llanowar Wastes

97%

4.0x

Cabal Therapy

97%

3.8x

Recurring Nightmare

97%

2.3x

Bone Shredder

95%

1.0x

Genesis

94%

1.0x

Duress

93%

3.4x

Nantuko Vigilante

88%

1.0x

Withered Wretch

86%

1.0x

flex Cards(30-80%)

Ravenous Baloth

78%

1.1x

Masticore

77%

1.0x

Tempting Wurm

62%

1.2x

Gaea's Cradle

53%

1.0x

Graveborn Muse

52%

1.0x

Mesmeric Fiend

48%

1.0x

Spike Feeder

41%

1.1x

Yavimaya Elder

38%

1.1x

Plague Spitter

37%

1.0x

Uktabi Orangutan

36%

1.0x

fringe Cards(<30%)

Palinchron

27%

1.0x

City of Brass

23%

1.6x

Yavimaya Granger

20%

1.0x

Hypnotic Specter

18%

1.1x

Living Death

15%

1.2x

Sadistic Hypnotist

15%

1.0x

Naturalize

13%

1.9x

Braids, Cabal Minion

13%

1.1x

Great Whale

13%

1.0x

Sylvan Library

12%

1.4x

Spore Frog

12%

1.0x

Krosan Tusker

11%

1.0x

2.4x

1.4x

1.2x

3.2x

2.0x

1.0x

1.0x

2.3x

1.7x

1.3x

1.3x

1.3x

1.0x

1.4x

1.2x

1.2x

1.0x

1.0x

1.0x

1.0x

3.5x

2.0x

1.3x

1.0x

1.0x

1.0x

2.0x

1.7x

1.7x

1.7x

1.7x

1.3x

Undiscovered Paradise

1.3x

1.0x

1.0x

1.0x

1.0x

4.0x

3.0x

2.5x

2.5x

2.0x

1.5x

1.5x

1.0x

1.0x

1.0x

1.0x

1.0x

1.0x

1.0x

1.0x

1.0x

1.0x

Thornscape Battlemage

1.0x

Thunderscape Battlemage

1.0x

Sideboard Anatomy

core Sideboard Options(>80%)

Naturalize

97.3%

3.0x

Engineered Plague

95.9%

3.2x

flex Sideboard Options(30-80%)

Withered Wretch

62.7%

1.0x

Uktabi Orangutan

61%

1.0x

Smother

44.7%

2.3x

Tempting Wurm

41.3%

1.2x

Sadistic Hypnotist

36.4%

1.0x

Bone Shredder

34.6%

1.0x

Tranquil Domain

33.4%

1.8x

Mesmeric Fiend

33%

1.1x

fringe Sideboard Options(<30%)

Spike Feeder

29.5%

1.1x

Faceless Butcher

29.2%

1.0x

Tsabo'S Web

23.1%

1.8x

Plague Spitter

20.8%

1.0x

Plaguebearer

18.5%

1.0x

Tormod'S Crypt

18.2%

1.5x

Duress

16.7%

1.2x

Spike Weaver

16.7%

1.0x

Ravenous Baloth

13.9%

1.1x

Braids, Cabal Minion

10.5%

1.0x

Gloom

10.2%

2.2x

Bane Of The Living

1.0x

Hypnotic Specter

8.3%

1.0x

Haunting Echoes

1.3x

Graveborn Muse

7.6%

1.0x

Masticore

7.4%

1.0x

Caller Of The Claw

6.7%

1.0x

Stromgald Cabal

5.9%

1.4x

Phantom Centaur

5.5%

1.0x

Xantid Swarm

4.2%

1.2x

Nantuko Vigilante

3.8%

1.0x

Monk Realist

3.6%

1.3x

Compost

3.6%

2.0x

Crumble

3.5%

1.5x

Phantom Nishoba

3.4%

1.0x

Natural Order

3.2%

2.1x

Phyrexian Furnace

3.1%

2.0x

Vendetta

2.8%

1.5x

Pernicious Deed

2.7%

2.0x

Swords To Plowshares

2.7%

2.7x

Radiant'S Dragoons

2.5%

1.0x

Cabal Therapy

2.5%

1.6x

Gilded Drake

2.4%

1.0x

Dust Bowl

2.4%

1.0x

Flametongue Kavu

2.3%

1.0x

Pyroblast

2.3%

2.0x

Gaea'S Blessing

2.3%

1.0x

Elvish Lyrist

1.0x

Spore Frog

1.0x

Goblin Sharpshooter

1.8%

1.0x

Seedtime

1.8%

1.0x

Red Elemental Blast

1.6%

1.2x

Diabolic Edict

1.6%

1.5x

Squee, Goblin Nabob

1.6%

1.0x

Sylvan Safekeeper

1.5%

1.0x

Monk Idealist

1.3%

1.0x

Phyrexian Plaguelord

1.3%

1.0x

Soul Rend

1.3%

1.0x

Eradicate

1.2%

1.0x

Recent Events Featuring this Archetype

Lega Milano 3/10 @ Milano (Italy)

2026-06-12•Milano, Italy•56 Players

Highest Finish: 23th

VIEW EVENT

Pastimes Premodern Showdown - 05/30

2026-05-30•Niles, IL, USA•47 Players

Highest Finish: 6th

VIEW EVENT

Premodern LeagueMay302026 (2026-05-30)

2026-05-30•Magic Online•15 Players

Highest Finish: 1st

VIEW EVENT

Premodern Challenge 32 Special (2026-05-28)

2026-05-28•Magic Online•64 Players

Highest Finish: 23th

VIEW EVENT

PM Local #13 @ Magic Lair (Torino, Italy)

2026-05-27•Torino, Italy•12 Players

Highest Finish: 1st

VIEW EVENT

Quick Facts

Tier3

Stylemidrange

Meta Share0.4%

Avg Lands20.6

Est. Price~$2616

Colors

Deck Weaknesses

Enchantment dependency — both Survival of the Fittest and Recurring Nightmare are enchantments with no built-in protection; the entire tutor-and-recur engine collapses if either is answered, and the deck runs no way to shield them from enchantment removal.
Graveyard reliance — every recursive loop (Recurring Nightmare swapping creatures in, Genesis returning creatures at upkeep, Squee, Goblin Nabob fueling free Survival of the Fittest activations) requires a populated graveyard; a static exile effect or a single well-timed graveyard clear removes the resource the whole deck is built around.
Slow setup against fast pressure — the deck assembles its engine over several turns using mana accelerants like Birds of Paradise, Wall of Roots, and Wall of Blossoms as blockers; aggressive decks can drop the life total before Recurring Nightmare ever resolves, and the walls stall the board without reducing the opponent's clock.
Sacrifice cost is exploitable — Recurring Nightmare is paid partly in creatures, and outside of a Deranged Hermit token swarm the deck typically controls only one or two relevant sacrifice bodies at a time; edict effects or forced-sacrifice mechanics drain the engine's fuel at the same time they remove a threat.

How to win with it

Mulligan any hand that lacks a mana accelerant (Birds of Paradise or Wall of Roots) or a piece of the engine (Survival of the Fittest or Recurring Nightmare); a keepable seven has at least one engine piece plus enough mana to cast it by turn two, since the deck cannot grind without the engine online and cannot race without acceleration.
The dream draw is turn-one Birds of Paradise into turn-two Survival of the Fittest: immediately discard a redundant creature such as a second Wall of Blossoms to tutor Squee, Goblin Nabob, and from there you have renewable discard fuel because Squee, Goblin Nabob returns from the graveyard to your hand each upkeep, so every activation pitches Squee, Goblin Nabob to fetch the next threat and chain through Genesis, Bone Shredder, Deranged Hermit, and Ravenous Baloth in the order the board demands.
Hold Cabal Therapy and Duress until you know what to name rather than jamming them blindly turn one; Cabal Therapy's flashback costs sacrificing a creature, so once Survival of the Fittest can keep fetching expendable bodies and Squee, Goblin Nabob keeps returning to be re-cast and re-sacrificed, you can flash it back repeatedly, making a patient targeted strip far better than a speculative early shot.
Recurring Nightmare forms a value loop, not a free lock: sacrifice an expendable creature to return your best threat from the graveyard, but remember Recurring Nightmare returns to your hand and must be recast for its full cost each use, and Squee, Goblin Nabob is your renewable fodder because it returns to hand at upkeep to be re-cast and fed back in; sequence a recurred Bone Shredder to clear a blocker before you commit Deranged Hermit so its Squirrel tokens have a clear path to lethal.
The grind plan pivots on Genesis in the graveyard: at each of your upkeeps pay three green mana to return whichever creature fits the moment, letting you rebuild through removal; once Genesis is online, prioritize retrieving Wall of Blossoms to refill your hand and Nantuko Vigilante to blow up a problem artifact or enchantment before you over-commit your win condition.
The kill with Deranged Hermit is to fetch it with Survival of the Fittest, cast it for the four Squirrel tokens it makes (which swing as 2/2s while it pumps them), then sacrifice it to Recurring Nightmare to dodge the echo and re-cast it from the graveyard for four fresh tokens each loop, so within two or three iterations the Squirrel army alongside Ravenous Baloth ends the game in one swing.

How to beat it

Kill Survival of the Fittest before the engine connects - once the deck has a free discard outlet like Squee, Goblin Nabob in play alongside Survival of the Fittest, it can tutor any creature in the deck at will with no resource cost; enchantment removal at the first opportunity, ideally before Squee hits the battlefield, cuts off the deck's ability to find answers on demand.
Exile creatures rather than sending them to the graveyard - Genesis and Recurring Nightmare both require creatures in the graveyard to function, so exile-based removal strands the engine completely; toolbox creatures like Bone Shredder, Nantuko Vigilante, and Withered Wretch lose all of their recursion value the moment they are exiled instead of destroyed.
Apply graveyard hate before Recurring Nightmare comes down - the deck spends its early turns filling the graveyard through Survival of the Fittest discards and Wall of Blossoms card draw; a static graveyard-disruption effect applied early forces Recurring Nightmare to enter an empty or depleted graveyard, collapsing the loop before it generates value.
Go wide with many small creatures so Recurring Nightmare activations trade down - each activation sacrifices a creature and returns Recurring Nightmare to hand to bring back one creature; against a wide board of cheap threats every loop only trades one creature for one creature, giving the Recurring Nightmare player no net board advantage while it spends mana and tempo to grind.
Race before Genesis stabilizes the loop - Genesis sitting in the graveyard lets the deck recover a creature every upkeep for 2G indefinitely; aggressive pressure forces the deck to spend mana on blockers like Wall of Blossoms and Wall of Roots rather than activating Genesis or Survival of the Fittest, and a fast enough clock wins before the recursion engine ever becomes self-sustaining.

Last Updated: May 2026